Follow
Share

So my mother in law did come to live with us briefly back in early July but it didn’t last and her son shipped her off to a specialty hospital after he saw how much work it was. Then we went on vacation and enjoyed the rest of the summer. Then my best friend was in a near fatal car accident in September in another state. She doesn’t have any family so I flew out to see her for a few days and my sister stayed at my home to help with the kids. When I was at the hospital, my husband called me to let me know he had to make a decision quickly about his mom’s placement and wanted to bring her home with us again but hire help this time instead of the nursing home. I told him absolutely not. We agreed she would be going into a nursing home after discharge. Now all of sudden, we are back to square one. I was so angry he would try this again when I was out of town. When I came back, we had a terrible argument and he told me I’m a horrible selfish wife and his mom is probably going to die in the nursing home because of me. Now my husband has stopped talking to me. Hasn’t spoken to me in weeks. Her siblings are mad at me. Nobody from his side of the family is speaking to me. I’m probably headed for a divorce soon just because I stood up for myself. I had a good cry about the other day. My life is a mess right now.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Yeah, well personally I would have divorced him a LONG LONG time ago, but that's up to you.

As to "you are a horrible wife and person". EMBRACE it. Own it. Tell him "I never claimed to be a good person or a good wife; I am what I am and what I am NOT is a wife who will have your mother in this house. The day she walks in I will walk OUT."

No one can stand up for you. You will have to stand up for yourself. I am sorry to be that blunt about it, but that's the truth. As my Mom always told me "I am raising you to be strong, capable and independent because THAT is what the WORLD will require of you". I will be grateful to that kind woman till the day I die.

And YES, your MIL will be dying in the nursing home. Just let him know that's a fact, and encourage him to visit her often and hold her hand while she goes.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report

I’m so sorry. I do hope you fully realize your MIL is going to die one day, and no matter the circumstances it will not be because of anything you did or didn’t do. Your husband and his family are being terribly unfair, and isn’t it remarkable that none of them are offering to host and provide caregiving for MIL? They just want to be angry at you for not giving in. Please visit a good lawyer, one known for advocating for women, I’m not suggesting divorce as of yet, but it’s always wise to get solid advice on where you stand. And remember, you and your health and wellbeing matter too
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Too bad your husband is so sneaky and "horribly selfish" that hes choosing to treat you like a criminal, along with his do-nothing family. Its so easy for them to pass judgment on what you're "Not doing" while they refuse to take the old woman in themselves! How rich!

Your husband has shown you who he is. Believe him. Plus, he's given you the power of God to say when his mother will pass! Ridiculous.

Best of luck to you.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
Fawnby Oct 2023
If I were so lucky to have the power of God to decide when this MIL passes, it would be yesterday. Funeral tomorrow. I would not attend.
(2)
Report
Not speaking to you is emotional abuse. Be sure to tell your lawyer what he's doing.

A first consultation with a lawyer is usually free. You get a half hour or an hour to discuss what options are available to you. You don't have to hire them at that point. This is the time to get that rolling.

Also, what is so bad about dying in a nursing home? Is it assumed that this is a horrible death? Who decided that? Husband and his shamily, none of whom want to provide hands-on care for her?

Obviously I haven't died yet, but I'm assuming that when I become room temperature, it won't matter whether I'm in a nursing home, on the floor of my house, or in a car that's been demolished by one of my senior citizen neighbors who decided to keep driving with low vision and "a little touch of dementia." If I were to choose, I'd pick the nursing home where I can lie quietly in my bed and embark upon my spirit's next adventure without pain and blood involved.

There's a whole lot of assumed nonsense at play here, such as you should be the one to take care of MIL. Brava to you for standing up to this slaughterhouse of a family. I really think that as a divorced woman, you'd be much better off. Create your own family from people who like you and move on with a real life that could eventually include another man who cherishes and loves you. This husband is not that.

Get on with it! There's a new chapter waiting to be written.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Southernwaver Oct 2023
Exactly, the a hole family members are mad at her but none of them have stepped up to take care of dear old mom. What a bunch of hypocrites. I don’t like them.
(4)
Report
See 1 more reply
While it isn't quite the same, I empathize with the "husband doing sneaky things while you're away" bit. Mine bought two houses without my consent when I was away dealing with my actively dying parents, and he still doesn't get why that was wrong. He thought he was saving me stress because I don't like owning rental properties, so if I have no knowledge of our joint assets being used to buy them, it's all good, right? 🙄

Whether his mom dies in a nursing home or yours is moot, because you won't be there. He has shown you who he is, and for me, the silent treatment would be the final straw.

His mom's death won't stop this behavior, and he'll use it on you for the rest of your years together. I suggest you leave NOW, right in the middle of all his dealings with his mom, and be sure to file for divorce immediately and demand the sale of the house where Mom is supposedly going to die.

Let him really see what stress looks like.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

This is so painful to me to read it that I can almost feel myself needing to cry.

Since you were blindsided, do you wish to attempt to salvage this? I know that if this happened to me, I’d want to know what brought about this unilateral decision and why, after deciding WITHOUT YOUR INPUT, to make it, he then did the180.

My mother lived a comfortable and pleasant 5 1/2 years in a fine local highly rated SNF. Then she died there, of course. And if he brings her into HIS home, she will die THERE.

Is it possible that a press of guilt has been gifted to him from other families? Guilt is a horrible, insidious enemy of logic.

When did you become selfish. It was obviously not while you were vacationing together. You say he “saw how much work” it was to have her live with you previously, but did he actually DO any of that hard work, or did most of it fall to you?

Did he express as you argued whether he’d thought about his children, and their needs?

It would certainly seem as though you do need sound legal advice, and counseling
for yourself if you would feel it would be helpful, and also for your your children .

I rarely say or feel this way, as painful as many of the stories shared here are, but I’m terribly disturbed by your heartbreaking post.

May you find peace and a solution that can offer you the comfort and consolation you deserve. And you DO deserve it.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
FedUpWife45 Oct 2023
I have been crying for days about this situation. My heart is completely broken 😞
(2)
Report
Wow, that is a lot. Your husband is mean and selfish. He wanted to dump that on you with no regard for your life with your children. Go see a divorce attorney for a (usually free) consultation. You need to know where you stand in case he files. This is so so so important. And pick a good one so if your husband decides, he won’t be able to use that lawyer.

If you really think divorce is on the table, you need to protect yourself, your children and your assets.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Ok I went back and refreshed from June. so I presume her family didn’t hire the caretakers who were promised to you when she moved into your home the first time?

So they are all liars too. Great.

Is your MIL dying and in hospice? No? Yeah, steer clear of that mess. The woman could live to 100 easily. How many years is that from now?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

You have every right to stand up for yourself. Is your husband an only child? It’s wrong of your husband and his relatives to be angry at you for not wanting to take care of your MIL.

Perhaps you should try counseling first to see if you can reach each other halfway. If counseling does not work to resolve this problem then you should head to divorce court.

This will be a tough one for you, but you need to do what’s right for your peace of mind.

Wishing you the best.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
MargaretMcKen Oct 2023
A coherent divorce threat, clearly worked out sensibly, is better than a counselor as a strategy to make divorce less likely.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
My suggestion is to prepare for divorce, whether or not it goes ahead. Last time things changed when not-so-dear H spent 2 weeks caring for MIL. Unless he gets around-the-clock in-home care, he will again end up caring for MIL. It may not last long, but you don’t want it to happen at all. And you need to be prepared if it does. So:

1) Open a bank account in your name. Transfer half the contents of any joint account into your new sole bank account. I normally stipulate ‘half’ for fairness, but if DH is still working and you aren’t yet, perhaps you take the lot, especially if you will be taking the children with you. DH can build up his own account again, or you can choose to put some back into his account if you get a job.

2) See a divorce lawyer, get advice about how to split assets – and anything else you ought to know, like child support. Also how to protect your share, even if you don’t go ahead with the divorce immediately.

3) Once you have your ducks in a row, let DH know. If he is still pushing for MIL to move in (or still giving you the silent treatment), move out yourself at least temporarily. Let DH organise the carers (able to roll a 300lb woman), find out where the gaps are that he has to fill himself, add up the costs, and get fed up once again – probably even before he moves her in.

4) Regarding “his mom is probably going to die in the nursing home because of me”. She is not going to die ‘because of you’. But she IS going to die. At home, or more probably at the end in a NH or a Hospice shelter – what’s the difference? Jesus died on the cross. Would that be a better way to go – just because it was God-given?

Make divorce a real possibility! It may happen, or it may fizzle away like last time.
Best wishes, Margaret
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
FedUpWife45 Oct 2023
I have my own bank account and a joint account with him.
(0)
Report
Get your ducks in a row while he isn’t speaking to you. Get your own account. Get yourself off of all joint credit cards and get your own. See a lawyer or two. Have an exit plan ready.

I am always so surprised at how many people have extended family involved in giving their opinion. I never saw my parents consulting nieces and nephews on how they should be caring for their siblings. It wasn’t any of their business.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

If your MIL’s siblings think she should be taken care of by family at home , they should take MIL home to their house with hired caregivers . I can’t believe they are trying to force this on you . They should put up or shut up . I suspect they really brainwashed your husband while you were away for him to do this 180, Flying monkeys are the worst !!

These elder siblings of your MIL may be using you as a message to their own children , putting them on notice , that they won’t go into a “home “ either and want their children to do for them , what they are trying to force you to do . You are the sacrificial lamb ( example ) for how caregiving is expected in this family .

You have kids at home , it would be disruptive to your entire family to have the MIL and hired help coming in .

Like the others said , get your Ducks in a row just in case it doesn’t work out . Would your husband be willing to talk to a marriage counselor who could maybe talk some sense into him ?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Do u have a job outside the home?

I am not going to jump on the divorce bandwagon, but I strongly suggest couples counseling, so that he can see how ridiculous he is being!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Southernwaver Oct 2023
I’m not jumping on divorce, but I absolutely 100% believe she needs to consult with a divorce lawyer to protect herself.
(6)
Report
See 1 more reply
I read ur first post from June 2021. Seems like MIL was a problem then. There was a debate then about moving her in. Then ur profile says she is in a NH. Was she taken out of the NH for a reason. Why did her son (ur husband?) send her to a specialized hospital? Did she have aggressive behaviour at the NH and at your home?

If so, and husband said she would not be coming back to your house, and then he wants to bring her back...I too would be mad and that is saying it nicely.

You mentioned in first post that husband is an only child and this is a cultural thing. Could the problem be that he is getting pressure from his relatives. And its thought that he, as the man of the house, should be telling u, this is how it is. So, he is taking his frustration out on you.

You also said in last post, that he travels. Reason why Mom can't come there. You have 4 children who need u 24/7. You cannot care for ur MIL too. If he wants her there, he needs to be doing the majority of care. The cost of having care even there 8 hrs a day is not cheap.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

https://www.agingcare.com/questions/am-i-being-unreasonable-468312.htm

Just so everyone is aware what OP has been going thru, here is OPs first post and an update from 2022 in that original post.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

And if she lives in your home, she'll never die?

What in blazes is wrong with him?
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
FedUpWife45 Oct 2023
He said he would rather her live with us getting proper care even if death still happens ( and it will) he doesn’t want her to die of neglect at the nursing home..
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
Are the NHs near you really bad?

My mom thrived on the care at a NH (one that accepted Medicaid, although mom was private pay) for 4 1/2 years.

What does he know about the NH nearby ?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

It’s over yall. Our divorce is moving forward. I’m completely heartbroken but this is his choice. Since I wouldn’t take care of his mother, he’s divorcing me….
Helpful Answer (12)
Report
AlvaDeer Oct 2023
To be honest you are well rid of him and the baggage he carries with him.
Thank you for the update. I know you will have read her often and know that you are far from alone in this.
(5)
Report
See 5 more replies
I’m so sorry your husband has made this choice. Please repeat often to yourself that you did not cause this, he chose it. It’s beyond sad. Thank you for the update and I hope you’ll let us know how you’re doing in the days ahead
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
FedUpWife45 Oct 2023
Im so sad about this. I love him but if he doesn’t want me anymore because I won’t look after his mom in our home, there is nothing i can do. His mom is clearly his number one priority. I feel like if I had just taken her in, we wouldn’t even be here right now. I wouldn’t be searching for a new home and uprooting my children. I’m so sad!
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
My Dh pulled that "My mom is going to die if we don't bring her here to care for her" ONCE with me. Maybe, 6 years ago.

I said "You can certainly have mom llive here. But I won't be here, and guess what? I'm going to take you to the cleaners, financially."

That was the one and only threat. I had to stand up for me, b/c he wasn't thinking clearly. He never lifted a finger to help his own father, my father or mother. He hadn't even SEEN my mom in the 4 years prior to her passing, yet he saw nothing wrong with bringing his mother to our house for 'us' (read: ME) to care for.

Without question, I would have divorced him. I even saw a lawyer about it.

Some years later--she is in Home Hospice care and he has to do 3-5 shifts a week, caring for her. It has dropped him to his knees, mentally and spiritually.

I basically forced him to choose--and I was SO MAD at him, I don't think I did talk to him for a couple weeks.

IN the 'end' 6 years later and she's not great, but she's still alive and requiring massive amounts of attention and care. She won't allow outsiders to care for her.

Had she moved in with us--well, there would have been NO 'us'. That's just one boundary I would not move, not one iota.

I do hope you don't have to divorce over this, Your husband really needs help. His family is probably happy that he's thinking of doing this-don't count on them for any support. If THEY wanted mom with them, it would happen.

Hold fast. Be a little patient, but do not let her bring so much as a spare toothbrush to your house.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
BurntCaregiver Oct 2023
I have said this many times. Good for you, Midkid.

I love it when people who are completely invalid and basically have the independence level of a toddler refuse to "allow" anyone but family to do for them.

Do they really have a choice? I think not. If your husband like so many others "allows" the needy elder to still be in charge then that's a choice. People who do this choose to allow the needy elder to be in charge.
They don't have to.
(4)
Report
One "flaw" in your husbands argument that his mother would die in a nursing home "because" of you...
I hate to break it to him but she is going to die sometime, somewhere anyway but it won't be "because" of you.
If his siblings are dead set against a Skilled Nursing facility maybe mom can move in with one of them and they can care for her.

I am wondering what happened that he "quickly" had to make a decision about mom's placement.
No facility would discharge her unless it was to a safe place that would be able to meet her needs.

If you are truly heading for a divorce make sure that you see a good lawyer and that you protect yourself and the kids. (just wondering where will your husband go with his mom?)
**Just saw the update that you are divorcing. PLEASE do not uproot the kids he should be the one to leave the house.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

I'm so sorry it has come to this. I'm pleased that it means you have clarity and courage going forward. Make sure you get a really great attorney and hopefully your future ex can be prevented from spending your community assets on any of MIL's care. Yes, he should be the one to leave the house if you have kids.

As others have stated: he is choosing this. You're not causing her unhappiness or death.

When I read that, "Her siblings are mad at me. Nobody from his side of the family is speaking to me" it made me think of one of my favorite adages:

"Wrong is still wrong even when everyone is doing it. Right is still right even when no one is doing it."

What you're doing is the right thing...don't waver!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
waytomisery Oct 2023
That’s true . Husband should leave. Fedup why are your children being forced to leave their home ?
(1)
Report
See the attorney before he gets a chance before you. This is to keep you financially sound because there are so many exes that were left destitute
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
BurntCaregiver Nov 2023
@MACinCT

What able-bodied, able-minded adult allows themselves to be completely dependent on another person so they risk becoming destitute if that relationship ends?
It's 2023 not 1953. Married women with kids also work at a paying job today.

The OP should get herself a good lawyer who will make sure she is treated fairly in the divorce. She should get a job though. Better sooner than later.
(1)
Report
How much do you want to bet that once he has been wiping his mom's butt for a couple of weeks, he will start looking into AL facilities pronto. Wouldn't surprise me if he comes to you begging for a reconciliation.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Isthisrealyreal Oct 2023
He isn't bringing his mom home, he's divorcing his wife because she won't accept being her caregiver.

This deadbeat never planned on helping his mom, only strapping his family to her so he can look like the good guy.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
FUW, please retain the best divorce attorney you can find and take this worthless boy for everything the law allows.

Do NOT leave your home, make him leave. And whatever you do, don't leave your kids, he can claim you abandoned them and create hell for you to get your kids.

Time to take of the muzzle mama bear and protect your kids from the joke you bred with. He has proven how low he will go, stand up now and defend you and your children.

Prayers for you and your children. These situations are rotten to the core.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
Isthisrealyreal Oct 2023
Time to take OFF the muzzle! Oops, sorry!
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
I’m so sorry, FedUp, that you are going through this. What troubles me the most is that you have 4 kids, the younger two I believe you said had disabilities in your other thread. Every one is cheering on the divorce, which solves the MIL problem, but my concern is for you to have the support and help you need with the children.
Was husband’s bid to care for MIL an excuse to get out of difficult parenting? I’m sorry I don’t have any words of wisdom for you, but please make sure that you and the children get your due, and that YOU get help as a newly single mother in a difficult situation.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This is puzzling. The divorce is going ahead. You don’t leave, you and the kids stay in the house. He removes MIL from care – WHERE DOES HE TAKE HER? If he brings her home, in spite of you, does he still go ahead with ‘his’ divorce? Or does he expect you to do the divorce leg-work? Or does he think you will just leave quietly? Or does he think you will crumple and care for MIL?

Perhaps in your shoes I would consider telling MIL as bluntly as possible that you do NOT want her in the house, that DH is divorcing you over the issue, and that she will be very UNCOMFORTABLE if she is moved in. Think about how to do it. Of course you don’t do food or care. She stays unchanged in her depends until DH gets home to do it. You put an external cuphook bolt on her door (easy to fit), and make sure that she doesn’t take over the living room to watch TV. Her room is the only part of the house that she ‘has’, at least while DH is not there. This is not a 'failure to care' on your part, because you have no obligation to care and you have made it quite clear. If DH threatens you, call the police.

If you do this, and DH doesn’t provide the care she needs (and how can he?), you call APS. If DH provides no services, you don’t have to, and she is not being adequately cared for.

DH is almost certainly planning to make your own accommodation difficulties force you to stay, and he assumes that you will then care. Don’t let it work that way. His ‘divorce’ threat is very very nasty. You can stand your ground and let his nastiness backfire – both on him and on MIL, so long as she knows what is going on. Perhaps put it all in writing, and give it to her – and the other family members. Keep a copy for the police, for APS, and for the divorce court.

'Divorce' your husband in your head, now, and realise that this is now a war!
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
FedUpWife45 Nov 2023
He has admitted to cheating and I really think this is why he really wants a divorce. There has to be another woman. So now the children and I have moved in with my sister ( her kids are off in college) and I have a job interview coming up. After the new revelation of him cheating, I’m making the right choice.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
11/7/23
This update got buried:

"He has admitted to cheating and I really think this is why he really wants a divorce. There has to be another woman. So now the children and I have moved in with my sister ( her kids are off in college) and I have a job interview coming up. After the new revelation of him cheating, I’m making the right choice."

Oh my. Yes, that is the correct choice. I hope you've seen a lawyer.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

So sorry. Take him for everything , leave him broke and his new woman will be wiping his Moms butt
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter