Follow
Share

I have a problem, my mother-in-law is not cognitive wise anymore and gets confused and very anxious and extremely needy where I am working and running back and forth all the time and getting run down myself with no life with my family. She is willing to some days to go to an assisted living but here's the problem.
My father-in-law who is better than her doesn't get out of bed 1/2 the time and refuses to go with her so she doesn't want to leave him.
I am between a rock and a hard place. I want to do what's right for my mother-in-law but my father-in-law doesn't want to leave his home.
Any advice would be appreciated.

Do nothing. Eventually something will happen, FIL will end up in the hospital, and you will then inform the hospital that he needs to be in AL.

He will never leave as long as others are caring for him 24/7.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to olddude
Report
MeDolly Aug 27, 2024
Right on, time for her to back out, stop being their crutch.
(3)
Report
Why are you working and doing all the running back forth ? What does your spouse do to help ?? These are not your parents . This is your spouse’s problem . Stop being the solution to this problem . Quit being a hands on caregiver .

You need to tell your spouse that this is not working any longer . Then both of you together tell your in laws that either they hire help to come into the home or both of them have to go to assisted living , whatever you think would work best . If they need help available 24/7 then assisted living is best .

Stop running over there . A wise social worker told me “ Stop helping them , let them fail , so they accept help from either hired help at home or assisted living “. You are propping them up so they are able to stay in their home with a false sense of independence . They are not independent .
Helpful Answer (19)
Reply to waytomisery
Report
CaringWifeAZ Sep 2, 2024
waytomisery, you and olddude said it well!

Hopefully forum1641 will heed your advice!
(2)
Report
Listen to Olddude in the comments because he's right. Take a HUGE step back and do nothing. You do not take any calls from your MIL while you're at work. You let that mess go straight to voicemail then listen to those calls when and IF you want to. Or block their number during the day. The running back and forth stops today. You AND your husband (these are HIS parents after all) can go there once or twice a week to check on them. You DO NOT take calls during dinner or when it's family time at your home, and no calls after a certain hour.

I'm sorry to say that many times something bad has to happen to get the loved ones into the proper care facility to meet their needs. I did homecare for 25 years and I will tell you from experience, that the more you prop their lives and the false independence they think they still have, the more stubborn they will become in their refusal to move to AL. So you stop running over there every time your MIL works herself up into a panic over nothing. Or because she's needy. You have to step back to help them. They need to be in AL and they will be if you stop doing for them at every turn.

Is there a POA active and in place? That helps, but if your FIL isn't incapacitated no one can force him to go or do anything. He's the next-of-kin to your MIL as well.

Call APS (Adult Protective Services) and report this situation. Tell them two vunerable elders with dementia are living alone and need to be placed. Ask the police to do regular wellness checks on them. They will and when they see your MIL's hysterical anxiousness and neediness, they will get APS to act. Then likely both of them get sent to AL, or at least your MIL does.
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report

forum1641, welcome to the forum. We really need more information, so when you get a chance please fill out the Profile page. That way we will know about whatever health issues your inlaws have. Such as does your Dad-in-law also have memory issues?


Could be Dad-in-Law is afraid of the cost, because it could cost them both around $10k per month to both be in Assisted Living (cost depends on location), and he could also doesn't want to admit he needs help.


As others have mentioned, time to cut back on running back and forth. Learn the phase "I cannot possibly do that". I wished I did that with my own parents.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to freqflyer
Report

You are enabling their poor decisions.
Why would they want to move when this is working well for them (no matter what it's doing to you).

Time for a long sit down talk, and then a withdrawal of your support and care, so they can recognize they need said to enter care. Give them all emergency numbers to call, and a list of agencies to call for paid support.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
PeggySue2020 Aug 27, 2024
I wouldn’t even bother with the talk as that’s likely been done before. The only thing they will ever get is action, or in your case, inaction.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
You are in the waiting stage. Two years ago my 94 year old parents didn't have a plan, my sisters and I had been propping them up for years. Their mobility and health were getting worse and worse and they refused to see it and got extremely nasty and suspicious when we brought up the direness of this situation.

All I can say is there will be an illness or a fall requiring a trip to the emergency room in the near future. You will just tell the medical staff that this is an unsafe discharge, that your in-laws cannot take care of themselves, let alone each other. That is what I had to do for my father and then for my mother. We placed them both in the local NH. They were together there for 9 months until my mother passed in June. Not the greatest thing to have done but it was what was needed. My sisters and I could no longer handle their care.

I also hope your husband is in the trenches with you and that this situation is not all falling on your shoulders.
Helpful Answer (12)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report
FixItPhyl Sep 3, 2024
Thank you for your straight-forward answer to this very difficult situation, because I have almost the same detailed problems described in the initial question, and have been at wits-end in how to handle it. I hope forum16... reads this one (and the majority of others giving same/similar advice) because it will eventually take YOUR health; it is like being on a hamster wheel and can't get off. As sad as it may sound, letting them "feel the pain" [hospitalization, etc.] through the consequences of not having a plan is the only way. They will continue putting everything on the anyone who will continue to enable them.

Peace be found.
(3)
Report
Honestly it doesn't sound like assisted living would be right for them. Even there they would still be running you ragged with their never ending neediness.

But if you want to get them into assisted living then you need to stop doing anything and everything for them.

FIL sounds like he has depression if he is healthy and rotting away in his bed most of the time. MIL sounds like she may need memory care or a nursing home at this point.

And where is your husband in all of this? I assume these are his parents so why isn't he the one running himself into the ground doing the propping up for mom and dad?
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to sp196902
Report

Their ages would be nice. 70s, FIL should be taking care of his wife. 80s, may need help but can still be main caregiver. 90s time for both to go into ALs. We have a few menvon this forum who care for their wives. Your FIL should be doing mostbof the work. You DH should be the one running back and forth and you supporting him.

When my SIL married my BIL she set boundaries from the beginning. You deal with your parents and I deal with mine. If my SIL had a problem with our MIL, my BIL handled it and visa versa.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

First..YOU are not between a Rock and a Hard Place it is your husband that should be between the rock and hard place. 'STOP your running around helping let your husband pick up the load for a while. I am sure once he gets a taste of what you have been doing he will have something to say about it.
OR
Both of you stop "helping" and let your FIL figure out that he really does need the help of Assisted Living.
If you and or your husband continue to jump in and do what needs to be done there is no incentive for them to make a change.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

I echo someone else - Welcome to the forum. This is a great place to get help and support. Sometimes the answers may be surprising to us, but believe when you hear the same advice numerous times, you should really consider taking it.

So, sorry, but you do need to set some serious boundaries and reclaim YOUR life. Your priority MUST be your personal family. Make a plan today and enact it tomorrow. They will whine and cry and maybe yell. That's OK. Of course they won't be happy. But are you happy with this situation?? Obviously not. Things will only change if you make them change.

Best of luck.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to againx100
Report

Why are you doing all the work? Where is your husband in all of this? Stop dropping everything to run to the rescue. Figure out what you are willing to do and do only that.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report

Leave them both alone. You’re giving them both the fantasy that they are okay to live on their own. Maybe not immediately, but at some point when you stop the proverbial running around like the chicken with its head cut off, they will falter seriously enough to require a move. You’re only making your life miserable by trying to prop them up and delay the inevitable. Relax and choose neither the rock or hard place, maybe the beach instead
Helpful Answer (10)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report
AlvaDeer Sep 2, 2024
I so agree with this. Our loving daughter here is contributing by enabling these bad decisions, and should withdraw from the mix.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
I am guessing you work from home while doing caregiving to in laws?
And who does all other chores? Cleaning, shopping, cooking?
Your husband needs to make arrangements for his parents i.e. AL. Two weeks to one month is reasonable to find one.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Evamar
Report

Have you looked into in-home care? This way you and your family can have your time together and the in-laws can get the help they need without an AL. It may be a good interim step to preserve your sanity and let them stay in their home. Of course, as soon as it's dangerous (e.g., mom wanders off, dad's health declines), you'll have to give serious consideration to an AL.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to AlottaStuff
Report

A hard one but just a suggestion
you tell father in law that mother needs to go into the care home or they will force it as you can’t cope anymore running rag back and forth you are getting ill ( the doctor says)
tell mother IL that father is being stubborn but once she’s in he will agree but won’t presently and you are not getting the care you both need
and agree a date with her
once father I-L sees she’s gone and misses her he may have second thoughts
why change if he can have it as he wants-
failing tvat ho speak to their doctor and discuss and hear what they say
eirher way
your health and life is important as well and if you’re father in-L has his faculties he can see you running headless and basically doesn’t care
so
you must
You are helping them
not giving up your life for them
good luck
just remember you matter as much as they do
another suggestion is a care person comes in x days a week and they get used to being looked after. Y a care person
forget the guilt trip- it her suggestion not justified
good luck
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Jenny10
Report
TouchMatters Sep 2, 2024
It sounds to me that the FIL (husband) is depressed and/or has dementia himself. I am not confident reading this woman's post that he is of sound mind to make these decisions.
(2)
Report
Take it from someone who has been at this for 15 years. Yes, my mother is 98. I’ve been caring for her since she was 83. Don’t listen to people who say, “move them into assisted living” or “start looking for AL and tell them they need to move”. That is a ridiculous suggestion because as you are discovering and I already know you can’t make a grown adult move. So settle into this reality: do what you can but start backing away. Set boundaries and let the chips fall. Sooner rather than later they will realize they need more help than you can give. I wish I had done this sooner. It may sound cruel but I let my mother flounder if she has a problem. She usually finds a neighbor to use and abuse. She gets her way most of the time but not at my expense anymore. I nearly died trying to be everything to her and she didn’t even flinch. I’m not a chicken so I don’t plan on running around like my heads been cut off anymore. Every professional (and most on this forum) I’ve talked with has told me that at this point I just need to wait until there is a major crisis and my mother will have no choice. That’s the choice she’s made: not to choose for herself ahead of time Maybe your in-laws will do the same.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Momsgoto
Report
Wordgirl Sep 2, 2024
Yes, completely agree with Momsgoto. Have tried every which way to get my dad, also 98 y.o., to accept help. A caregiver. Assisted living. Fully cognizant, he fights me on every level. An only child 1000 miles away with no other family to assist, I have decided to let the chips fall. You cannot force someone into AL and then hope for the best. It is very sad to end a hard life this way but a person who has been my way or the highway all their life won’t change in old age.
(6)
Report
See 3 more replies
IMO it is tie to stop doing everything for them a false sense of being independent has been created.

I would also tell my husband that I am retiring from this position, they are his parents not yours. It is his responsibility not yours.

Time to back off and get your life back. Good Luck!
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to MeDolly
Report

If your FIL doesn’t have cognitive decline, work with him to make a list of the things he and your MIL don’t do for themselves. Then check off what you are willing to do for them. Be fair to yourself. Let him know they are responsible for the rest of the list. Then remove yourself from the equation. Don’t help them solve it. They may have to fail. I know it’s difficult. But as long as you keep enabling them to keep up their charade of independence they won’t have to change their situation..

And don’t let them tell you how selfish you are for choosing your own family over them. I am still seething over having received that speech.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Anabanana
Report
TouchMatters Sep 2, 2024
Good support / advice.
Yes, at times it is only when the sh--t hits the fan that a person realizes that 'this isn't working' and becomes more willing to make changes. Other times, they are unable to due to dementia.

This woman needs 'positive self-talk' to learn to put herself first - then her immediately family, then others. It takes intentional inner work to do this and doesn't happen over night. Although, it is often 'times like this' when loved ones (elder parents) change that the entire family dynamic starts to change - because it has to. Unfortunately, so many adult children do not understand dementia and 'ask them what they want to do' - talk to them as if they have full capacity of their cognitive functioning. We, as a society, are NOT trained on how to deal with a person inflicted with dementia.

Thank you for supporting this woman to set realistic, healthy boundaries (and priorities) for herself. Gena
(2)
Report
Start touring nearby places.
Move MIL to meet her needs.
FIL may follow because there will not be anyone at home to assist him.

There are facilities that are more independent, but serve 3 meals, transport to doctor's, and do laundry.

MIL might improve without FIL needing her, maybe wearing her out?
She may be isolated, and a change can do her good. There are people there to socialize.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Sendhelp
Report

OP has now had 19+ answers of the advice she asked for. It’s time for OP to come back and tell us what advice she can use and what she is going to do. And if not, why not.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

Since these are your in-laws, why isn't your husband manages or participating in these family needs. If he is, you didn't mention him. It sounds like you are taking on all the responsibility.

Your MIL doesn't have the cognitive functioning due to parts of the brain impaired and brain cells dying. Yes, depending on the type of dementia, she will continue to be confused, anxious and needy.

If her husband, your FIL, doesn't want to 'go with her' (which I do not understand) - in essence, if he is of sound mind, have legal authority to make decisions on their / her behalf, there is little you can do.

It sounds like your husband needs to intervene on behalf of his parents (vs you) in getting both of them medically assessed for dementia. Once this is documented, you/r husband can see about getting some / more legal control for decision making on their behalf.

Do learn about dementia, how the brain functions, and what parts of the brain manage what thoughts/behavior. Google TEEPA SNOW. Read her website, webinars, You Tubes, books. Remember: Their brain is doing what it can while losing cognitive abilities. They cannot necessarily 'help' the decisions they make. Your FIL may also be depressed - staying in bed 1/2 the day. He likely has other medical issues needing to be addressed.

If you do not set limits of what you will (or learn what you can do), you will burn out. This 'isn't your problem' may sound cruel, however you need to figure out, perhaps with your husband, and perhaps your MIL's husband what you can do based on what they are willing to do.

At some point, you need to let go. Since you already say 'you have 'no life with my family,' you are way beyond that red flag. S-T-O-P. Realize you can and must set limits and ultimately, if your MIL's husband doesn't want to 'do' anything and he is of sound mind, there is likely little you can do.

If it were me, I would discuss with my husband and [perhaps] call Adult Protective Services (APS) and see what they say. They may make an assessment visit.

You are only between a rock-hard place because believe you are. You have put yourself in this position (no criticism). It is a matter of realizing your limits, responsibilities, and creating boundaries of what you will and will not do, and realizing you need to let go 'more' and focus on your immediate family.

I am perplexed as to why you do not mention your husband as these are his parents.

It is OFTEN very difficult to 'do the right' behavior for older people / family members due to their resistance. My friend-companion had a stroke and when the paramedics came to his apt they assessed him medically and said he needed to get in their ambulance and go to the hospital. He didn't want to go. I was there and having legal authority, I made the decision. He was then taken to a nursing home after hospitalization/assessment. He could not make a decision that would serve his best interest. Although, out of respect to him and many other elders who are 'fed up' and had enough ... if. they do not have the will or desire to keep living / taking care of their self - as they decline mentally, psychologcally and physically (in all ways), it is their decision. I respect their decisions, although unfortunately 'most of them' are made when cognitive functioning is impaired.

Let us know what you decide to do. Take a deep breath. Do 5 good things for yourself each day (talk to your kids / husband, garden, have some fun, go out to the park ... turn your thinking around and do not make this your burden. You can only do so much and then you need to let go.

Gena / Touch Matters
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to TouchMatters
Report

Let her go . He doesnt want to go . Maybe he is really Burnt out too.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to KNance72
Report

If MIL's husband won't leave their home, let HIM take care of his own wife. Why are you running there? What exactly are you doing for MIL she can't do herself? Are you working full time and running over to MIL after work?

STOP running yourself ragged with MIL's needs. If MIL won't go to AL because her husband refuses, then her husband is who takes care of her needs, NOT YOU.

You cannot keep being an unpaid caregiver. STOP running over there! Tell MIL you work and have your own family to take care of. Start saying NO.
Why isn't your husband dealing with his parents?

Whatever you do, DO NOT move in-laws in your home.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Dawn88
Report
JeanLouise Sep 2, 2024
Well said
(1)
Report
Is your husband involved with his parents caregiving at all?
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to JeanLouise
Report

You have to stop. It will feel selfish and wrong, at first. But you will get better at being practical and at building boundaries.

When I told my stepdad that I couldn't keep coming over to do things for him and mum, and that he needed to increase the care, he thought I was being selfish and unreasonable.
He said there was no point in getting carers because he wouldn't know when he wanted the help (but he didn't mind getting me out of bed, or calling me at work to "pop round" most evenings, even though I don't drive, so I would get home too late for dinner etc.)
I pointed out that he always seemed to need me to pick up their prescriptions, despite the pharmacy offering a delivery service, or to go after work , between 5 and 6 each evening to make their tea. These jobs could easily be done by others. If he agreed to move to a retirement facility that had carers on-site, I wouldn't need to be called out every time he fell, including in the middle of the night. I cared, but I also needed to go to work and keep my job.

In the end, one of Mum's hospital stays meant they needed to move to a facility with a lift and for a care package to be in place before they'd discharge her to her own home. He has moaned constantly about how much he hates it there and how it's my fault that he agreed to move, but I know he's safe (Mum died recently).

He did everything he could to make me feel guilty for not dropping everything to go into hospital with Mum, after the first couple of times when I spent over 24 hours from the time of the ambulance being called, Mum being assessed and monitored in A&E, then being admitted onto a ward and liaising with the doctors. I missed too much time off work and got ill from the circumstances.

Then, he would pile on the guilt if I didn't visit Mum every single day, although I was there most days (he visited once a week).

I know that I did the best for my mum, even when I backed off. She needed professional care and that only happened when I told the hospital that I couldn't prop them up any more.

You have to be cruel to be kind, as the saying goes. I don't think it's cruel; I think it's sensible.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MiaMoor
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter