Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
1 2 3
All in all, I love the old man a lot. He is sweet and pretty funny, too. And Kitty you were spot on! I think about those things all the time! I just feel my fiancee could use a break. I have been in the home a year and a half and I aready need a break so I could imagine 10 years of the same thing everyday. I also think not living in that home would help me get closer to the grandfather and I`d enjoy his burnt biscuits a lot more if I didn`t have to scrub the oven afterwards...lol. Thanks for all the support and comments.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Poor N1K2R3, it is that kind of judgement God himself frowns upon. Thank you, though, for your concern and kind comments.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

The comments keep coming and the story continues....lol. I am quite close with my fiancee's younger sister. She is the one I am able to really vent, too and go to for advice. Since she has been in this family all her life, she knows how things became to be this hell of a mess I am stepping into now. According to her, the grandparents we're the main caregivers to my fiancee and his 3 siblings. As I said before, the mother was pretty brutal to them. A young, single mother who was desperate to find a man and even pushed her kids aside to do so. As time went on, her kids grew up knowing their grandparents to be the providers and caregivers. When they became adults, the oldest sibling, my fiancee's half sister, got involved with an addict who would rather support his habit than pay their bills so she would rely on her grandfather to "loan" them money for bills, food and school clothes for their kids. My fiancee's brother was the type to impregnate, marry, divorce a woman and skip out of town when he was forced to pay child support. He would always find a way to get money from his grandfather. My fiancee was out on his own at this time and was supporting himself. His younger sister got married and has two wonderful kids and a great job. So the grandfather was pretty much the family ATM for the two siblings and on occasion his own daughter (my fiancee's mom). When he told them there would be no more "loans" - they all vanished.

As for some of the posters comments about my fiancee's living conditions - men are messy by nature. My mother cleans up after my father. My sister cleans up after her boyfriend and his company. My little brother's room has no floor only piles up dirty laundry and video game controllers and dishes. My point is, the grandfatgher had someone to clean up after him for 41 years! I bet he never lifted a single finger or washed a dish in all his married days...so why would he start now when he has a grandson and his fiancee to do it for him? My fiancee is a very clean guy. His room, now our room, is always spot-less. In fact, I am barely out of the bed before he starts making it! The grandfather is the one causing the mess. Everyday there is at least a full garbage to go out in the afternoon, and one more before bed. He urinates all over the bathroom floor, the toilet seat and lid. He throws dirty tissue and paper towels into the bath tub and shuts the curtain. Water is constantly splashed all over the sink counter. Believe me, we both clean the bathroom alone, 5 or so times a day! The kitchen counter and floor are cleaned everyday, garbage is changed around the clock. Newspapers are being collected and tossed away. It is not like my fiancee is rolling around in the garbage or adding to it. He even splurges on expensive home and industrial cleaners to kill germs and eliminate bad smells from the urine and garbage.

My fiancee once made the first attempt at a home repair by calling a plumber to fix and replace the toilet. To our surprise, the grandfather has flushed food, paper towels, rags and even dry cement into the toilet. The plumber also found cardboard (empty toilet paper rolls ripped and flushed) and an old house key. He told us he was surprised the toilet worked at all and didn't flood everytime it was used. Within a few months, we we're having problems again and now our basement ceiling leaks everytime the toilet is flushed.

When we asked the grandfather about making any repairs he said he was fine with the house the way it was and that he didn't feel repairs we're necessary. More recently, during a trip to Lowe's, he bought a couple 0.98 cent a piece tiles and cut them up and nailed them to certain parts of the kitchen floor where he felt there were cracks. I mean..THIS is the stuff we are dealing with. Any normal person would look into replacing the WHOLE floor, not one little corner.

My fiancee and I have access to showers both at work and at our gym. We are able to keep our part of the house clean and tidy no problem. It would be nice to wake up and shower or shower before bed at HOME, but for now it works. We have both put money into the house as far as buying new dishes, a new toilet and getting new furniture for his grandfather since he refuses to spend any money whatsoever on that sort of stuff. My thought is, this is NOT our home. My fiancee has no interest in living here or repairing it to live here once his grandfather is gone. So he won't put money into the home. Plus as I said, he is covering the expenses on his grandfather's home, our gym memberships, travelling expenses, our food and other activities that require money. He is also paying half my student loans with me. I am not able to get a work visa. I have applied for a different visa and the work visa is included but won't be issued for 1-3 months. We are in the very beginning stages of our visa journey.

Outside the home, my fiancee and I are so much alike. I love the man he is and I want to marry him. I don't want to marry his grandfather. And although he tells me how much he appreciates me helping him out and tolerating the situation, I still feel at times he takes advantage of our relationship and expects me to do the things I do for his grandfather. Because my fiancee works afternoons, I am home for 8 hours a day mon-fri alone with his grandfather. The things you can hear an 84 year old man say when he thinks nobody else is around.

As for the questions, what kind of woman would I be if I hadn't snooped? He told me about an ex he was with for 5 years. Apparently, their relationship was too rocky for marriage and the girl had her own issues. His sister told me my ex was a womanizer in his past and was never serious for long but she has seen a new man since I was introduced to her last year.

Although my fiancee's family is torn and he is enabling his grandfather to live an unhealthy, untidy lifestyle, he means very well. He still attempts to take his grandfather to the DR (although we are denied everytime). Instead we have been going to my fiancee`s DR and asking questions about how to keep his grandfather healthy and etc. My fiancee has told me several times he never knew it would be like this and all he wanted to do was make his grandma happy and he can`t wait until we live in our own house and have our own family...I just feel his grandpa will never let it happen. My fiancee once told me the whole reason he actually moved in was his grandfather would call him and make up stories that teenagers would hang out in the park by his home and bang on his doors and windows...of, course...it wasn`t true but that is how the grandpa is. He would rather lie than just ask for company or help.


I don`t WANT his grandfather to go into a nursing home. I want my fiancee to finally move out into a house of our own to give himself and yes, me, a break. I just feel a nursing home would be more suitable as I don`t believe the grandfather would be able to live alone.

Oh, I just saw a couple other questions. Of, course we don`t have company over! There is nowhere to have company as the grandfather occupies the living room and his dogs constant barking occupy the whole house.

I don`t tell my parents or friends. All they know is his grandfather `gets sick` and that he likes to make up stories and that he can be cheap....which is a huuuuge understatement. I don`t tell them because they would all tell me to run as well.

I don`t want to leave my fiancee because he has done nothing wrong except to care for someone and enable them to live however they like. And who am I to come into his grandfather`s home and tell the old man it`s time to change? One thing I am comforted by is that my fiancee calls it ``gramps house`` whenever he refers to being there or going there. Which let`s me know he doesn`t feel at home there either...and that would also help him move more easily.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

STL: Say bye-bye to your fiancee and his grandfather. You don't belong in this picture. You come across as selfish and distorted. Give these people a chance to find another soul who cares about THEM and everyone will be happier. Bye.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Please forgive me for laughing, but your story has made me laugh because grandfather reminds me of my dad who was 84 when he died 2 1/2 years ago. My dad was an old mountain man and quite contrary though very sweet, too. It is a difficult combination to deal with because most folks on the outside knew my dad as being a good hearted, hardworking man who would do anything he could for them, but his family had to take his contrariness and dirtiness, especially my mom. She had so much dirt to clean up over the years, poor thing. And scrubbing the work clothes on a washboard because of the dirt, even though she did have a washer and dryer. It was only when I was caring for her when she was terminal and a cousin was paid to look after dad and the house, that my cousin said "Poor, ____, she had to deal with this all these 56 years?" I smiled and said, "yes." Finally, someone understood the dirt that seemed to appear from no where and the stubbornness.

I do not know what I would do in your circumstances, because he is not your family unless you choose to be apart of it. He is from a generation where they had to be frugal because of the Great Depression and the rationing of World War II and that mind frame never left them. Actually, I think it would do our own generation a bit of good if they could learn this lesson a little bit. Sometimes it can be a bit frustrating, though. Also men of his generation were more likely to be waited on by the women of the family or in this case the younger family members. I have no idea if grandpa is like he is because of the life long experience or if now that grandma is gone and not calling the shots that he is taking advantage of a good thing. If anything this is good experience for you as a social worker to not always judge a book by its cover. That even with the best care, it can be a challenge for a caregiver to keep a person clean, fed, and home in shape. As for going to the doctor, it is the grandfather's decision as long as he is deemed sane enough to make his own decisions.

You need to think long and hard about what you are willing to do and have a good long talk with your finance. Good Luck.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Get out while the gettin' is good, woman. I cannot believe that you would consider a life that already sounds like a horror. Get your own place and seek therapy. When the air is clear, and your fiance 'ever decides that he would like a clean home without all the drama, maybe you can try again.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

What kinda dog does granpa have? Is it a small or large dog and how old? Is it hard to take care of?
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Wow, so much advice! But I feel compelled to add a few things:
0. It is true that kindness is the most beautiful thing in the world and should drive our actions, but it can be cruel to be kind.
1. the dog: that is animal abuse and need to stop immediately. Take the dog out of there and bring it to a no-kill animal shelter or placement agency for this very purpose. Council on aging can probably advise.
2. power of attorney? does your fiancee have power of attorney? if not, he needs it so he can stop letting someone with a child's mentality run your lives. If he had poa he could get the house fixed with grandpa's money.
3. Would you let a 5 year old decide for themselves and worse, for you, how to live life? He may be an adult physically but he isn't one mentally.
4.5. If you have kids with this man, will they be allowed to do, eat and mess what they want at all times? Somebody has to be the grown up.
5. Take the emotion out of it and let reality and logic rule for one hour. During that hour sit down and write down what advice you'd give to a friend in your situation.
6. Igloo' has a point, don't become a statistic.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Wow big age difference between you and your fiancee, that alone can be a challenge. I would have to refer to what Ed said about in short, 'how much do you love this man'. If you are ready to be his wife and make a life and a home with him...well grandpa kinda comes with the package...cause there is nothing deeper than family in this world. I would put all the cards out on the table now since you are soooo young and think about the goals you have in life. If they are just having a home and family with your husband..then hang on to the man you have if you love him to bits. Grandpa will not live forever, you just never know how long you have with him. I forgot to mention in a previous post, perhaps there is someone else who can help caregive. I know you are of limited means but maybe sometimes you need just someone else with a fresh prespective to make the house more manageable. Perhaps you can get a part time job...but I don't know if that is in any violation for Visa's. Is there any other family that can possibly come or a neighbor to come and sit with him, or help clean up. The older folks tend to get wierd and messy..it just comes with the territory with the deterioration of the brain..they just don't know any better. If you peruse through Aging Care there are a lot of gross stories...a lot! So acess your situation and see if this is what you want for your life...do you love him enough to endure what comes. Sometimes grass seems greener on the other side and then you find it is not.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Ok I have now read all the postings since the original.

stl - whatever your primary language is, translate this and make it your mantra:
"this man is out to control me, I need to get out and away"

This whole internet/visa is set up for enslavement and entrapment. He has you totally beholden to him, once you get married you will be legally bound to him.
From his perspective this is a win-win, he get's a young, pretty, educated sex buddy who can work her butt off for him & grandpa and since he's the "sponsor" he has total control. IMHO this is never good. Even we are all wrong and he is the Archangel Michael - he'd always have you cleaning another part of his wings.

Go and see the consul for your country to see what your options are. You can do some of this on-line. Do you have your passport or does he have it? Have you had any of the ICE meetings regarding your visa? ICE has a whole division that deals with these sort of issues.

Also is there anyway you can have family visit? That was a great idea, Like for a month. So that it establishes that in the future your family will be doing this - that you have people and they will be there eventually.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

stl, what does you family back home think of all this? What do the friends you've made in the US think of your situation? Are you comfortable inviting them into your "home"?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

stl - welcome to the site. It's quite a world of insight, experience & opinion.

For me, Naheaton is spot-on with the assesment.

This has the making for a reality show and it isn't pretty. You're what, 24, 25? Educated with a job, making & saving money, correct? These should be your years for adventure, exploration and doing things for yourself before you settle down and start a family or start a business or get heavy into work. If you marry him, remember this is a legal contract. Whatever expenses he does involves you and your money. If grandpa goes into a home, and your then husband signs him in you could find yourself paying for grandpa's care.

As a cynic, something about this doesn't pass the smell test. You met on the internet? If you can get into his laptop and dig down to see if he approached other women on becoming his wife/partner/caregiver. What are his finances like, does he have other legal commitments, like education loans, that if you could have to contribute to pay off.

There's probably good reason's why grandpa's other family doesn't want anything to do with him. Talk with them to get their perspective - especially those that married into this family.

Please keep in mind, that the problems for the elderly, like dementia, do NOT get better. There are med's that can keep their cognitive ability that they are at today from slipping as far but nothing reverses the aging process. Grandpa could live another 10 years maybe more. If he already was a hoarder & a miser, that is who he is and it will only become more intense.If your finance's plan is that you are all about becoming the co-caregiver for gramp's, is that what you want for the next decade for yourself?

As others have said, WAIT! and ask ?'s and if needed snoop around. But as I said, I am a cynic. Good luck and keep us posted.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

To make a long story short. RUN ! Don't walk....out of this situation.
I certainly don't understand anyone living this way for 10 years and I certainly don't understand a woman that just graduated from college thinking so little of herself or desperate for a mans affection to even consider getting involved in this mess. It will only get worse when there is conflict over the situation.,
I realize this sounds harsh but I call them as I see them.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

wow is right. this sounds to me like a real mess, and yet, I can identify so much with all of it. When I married, my hubby's Dad was alive. Broken home, mom ran out on my hubby when he was six months old, so Dad raised him with the help of Dad's mom. Now that Dad was living alone, we had a true hoarder situation, with used tired stacked in the living room. Dad used to stack his cigs in the ashtray like some kind of sculpture, and not ever empty them, merely getting a new ashtray when the cigs were falling out of the old. It was a fire hazard, and a mouse ridden house. I never lived there.

However, my hubby had the same habits. When I moved in with him, there were three motorcycles in the dining room. lol They took them out in the spring to ride, and I promptly put a couch there and wouldn't let the bikes back in. I lived for a year without a kitchen sink, doing dishes in the bathroom when I was eight months pregnant. Hubby's dad owned the house, and we were supposed to be fixing it up so he could rent it out. Um, yeah. No sink for a year, because the man was too cheap to get one installed.

I had a job retraining hubby to do repairs on the house, pay bills on time, etc. Now, 26 years later, and a huge amount of fights and me standing my ground, we get along just fine. His dad died the same year our first child was born, and we used the insurance money to repair the house, including the sink. It was sad it had to come to that. I felt and still do feel, guilty for feeling relief at his death, because it freed my hubby from a very destructive relationship with his dad. (And allowed me to truly run the household, in all honesty)

You, on the other hand, have the option of dealing with things very differently than I did. You have the benefit of logical thinking. I was just a kid who wanted to be with my man, and I had the common sense of a turnip. You need to decide how you want to live. Then, when you have that clear in your head, discuss it with your man. See if he has the same idea as you do. Clean, healthy environment, or cluttered, filthy one. Period. If he wants what you want, then discuss ways to reach that goal. He may suggest gramps moving into assisted living, or he may not, but gramps is not your issue. Your man is your issue. He can choose to deal with gramps however he wants, but he has to be your partner in achieving whatever future goals you BOTH have. If the goals do not agree, you've chosen the wrong man.

I compromised with mine. The back yard is his to wreck as he pleases. It's fenced, and holds junk, an old car, and a shed with all his tools in it. The front yard and the house are my domain. The basement is my mother's, since all her stuff is stored there just in case it's needed, which is the compromise I made with her to go to the nursing home. Soon enough, I'll weed out the basement, and slowly get rid of the stuff she never asks about. Compromise is always the name of the game in a relationship, but you still have to have a few things you will not budge on. This is your life you're discussing, not some hypothetical situation. You need to state your needs to your fiancée, and let him help you take care of them. Period. Without his input, we're all talking in circles. What does he want, and how does he want to get to his goal? And then look at it again, and see where you might be willing to compromise to meet his needs. Such as caring for gramps. Do NOT enable the enabler. Sounds to me like getting away from his grandfather might be the best thing for him, just as it was for my hubby and his father. If he truly wants to be your husband, then he does need to choose to spend more time and effort on your relationship than his gramps. That doesn't mean ignore gramps, but it does mean his future with you takes precedence.

Ah, good luck on all of this. I'm pulling for you. Now, I'm off to check on the ramp we're building for my hubby. He's heading home from a two month hosp and nursing home stay on Wednesday. :D And yes, he's also my best friend in the world, in spite of all the heartaches over the years. A lot of work goes into any relationship, and I got lucky the one I chose was a decent, caring, loving type in spite of everything.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

I guess I am in the minority here on answers. I believe you have hell of a fiance there and I would do whatever it takes to keep him. Let him make ALL of the decisions and support him. If he wants to let his grandfather drink pepsi and eat frozen dinners, thats fine, after all, is is 84 shouldnt he do what he wants by now. Dementia is certainly in this picture and it wil only get worse. He wont live forever, and how can you ask him to move him out? The poor guy has problems breathing and might be nasty but he isnt himself. I think if you yourself were to ever get ill, or in a severe accident, your fiance (husband) would do the same for you. I would hold on to that guy, no matter what. I have a wonderful husband that supports me in my Mom (same circumstances almost) who lives with us. He is so proud of me, and so are my adult children. If I chose to place her, its up to me, not my husband and he is with me regardless. Think about how badly you want this marraige. Best of luck.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

am I wrong to offer up the Reader's digest version?
Probably, but here it is anyway....

omg! run!!!

lovbob
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

When it comes to relationships, there is one rule that does not change: what bugs you a little now, will bug you a lot more as time goes on. So evaluate what bugs now and multiply it by 10. If you think you can handle it - marry the guy. If not take a nice loooong break and see if distance can help you iron out some of these issues. I guarantee you that if the fiance does not put your first now, he never will.
I am a little confused by the "sponsor" thing. I am wondering if there isn't a secondary consideration here. Did he think that, in addition to a fiance, he was getting help with gramps? Were you thinking that, in addition to a wonderful guy, you were getting an opportunity to work here in your field? So much going on here. I think you are both a little disappointed that things aren't quite going as planned.
Regardless, your fiance cannot be held to a promise made years ago when he did not know how much gramps woud be demanding of him. I can tell you sitting around in his own filth and doing nothing to help himself is creating an unreasonable demand on your boyfriend.
There are MANY ways to help someone. Putting your life on hold, and being a slave to a slob is not one of them.
Gather some information about assisted living and nursing homes. Sit down with your fiance and go over all the options. You sound both knowledgable and compassionate. Also, being in social work will help. Come up with a time line for changes and stick to it. This will help his grandfather get used to the idea of change.
If your fiance refuses, you have bigger problems that the grungy grandpa.
Good luck...this is one of the most complex scenarios I have seen in the forum.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

STL:

To paraphrase Gladys Knight in "Midnight Train to Georgia," would you rather live in his world than live without him in yours? If that's the case -- and until he makes a decision how and where to live the rest of his life -- you better get used to the baggage. Stubborn grandfather, barnyard-style house, and everything else you didn't think was so bad two years ago when you met him in cyberspace.

In a way, I don't blame you for falling in love with him. He sounds like a terrific man with a heart bigger than he is. Now you're having doubts about jumping the broom, daunted by the prospect your lot might not change for a while, and taking a plunge into a sea of uncertainty if your own dreams have to be deferred.

In Spanish, there's a saying for those wishing to get married but don't have a nest of their own yet: "El casado casa quiere." In other words, married people need their own house. Grandpa's stubbornness is designed to let you know you're just a guest -- or some sort of interloper who doesn't want to hit the road. Your fiance seems to be stuck in a symbiotic relationship with him. But Instead of riding into the sunset with the woman of his dreams it's a lot easier to bring her in, expect her to help with the caregiving because "you're as good as married," and put up with all kinds of BS until he's ready to prioritize.

It takes two to tango baby, and Love isn't the only reason you got engaged. You want to build a life together, have children, share warm and fuzzy feelings with a best friend and makes you do silly things.

He's a good man, but you can't go on living like that forever. I'd take him out to dinner and talk about how you both feel about this situation and what you can do together to improve it. ... Sometimes men need a little encouragement from a woman who's not afraid of take charge. If he respects your opinion, he'll listen. If he feels like you're nagging, don't be surprised if he wants to take a break from the relationship. ... Be gentle with him.

-- Ed
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Ah, more details come out.

You want children and a clean, well functioning home? Ain't gonna happen here, honey. Get yourself disentangled from this disfunctioning household if you want to meet your goals.

You are afraid that if you marry you will be taking care of Grandfather and then, because of the difference in your ages, be taking care of your husband? Yup. That is a highly likely scenario.

You resent them now a little bit? That is nothing to how the resentment will build if you let yourself be trapped in this situation.

Your fiancee withheld significant information from you when you first met (online)? Ask yourself if that is a characteristic you want in the father of your children.

This man cannot afford to live rent-free, pay only utilities and food, and cannot maintain a house in livable condition? He is sponsoring you financially now -- what did he use that money for before he met you? Not fixing the plumbing, that's clear. So how will he suddenly be able to afford to pay mortgage payments on his own home, pay taxes, pay utilities, buy food, and support you and children? Even when you work, is that going to make enough difference? Do you love him enough to be willing to live in poverty? You see what his current standard of living is like.

There is not escaping -- unless you choose to escape.

I don't know much about the conditions on Visas. You are here under someone's financial sponsorship. Can you get a work Visa? Can you apply for citizenship (and do you want to)? Is going home and starting life there with your education a viable option for you?

You sound like a very logical, intelligent, observant person. You can surely make your own way in life. Maybe there are technicalities that will be hurdles for you to start with, but you have youth, vitality, and intelligence on your side. You'll make it.

Now that I know how old you are, I am going to give you the same advice I give all my grandchildren: Do not marry (or live with someone) until you have supported yourself for at least a year. Learn to be independent before you become interdependent.

You are very wise to be questioning your future in this situation. Best of luck to you as you sort this out.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Well jeannegibbs, the whole story could probably go on forever and it would just get to the point of sounding bizarre and wildly exaggerated but I assure you it's not. The grandfather has bought and paid off the house. When I say bills I mean utilities and taxes, not rent. The grandfather is not contributing a dollar to his own home. He would rather sit with nothing than to give up a penny. My fiancee is on a limited salary as he is currently as I said paying at the grandfather's house and supporting me (he is my financial sponsor as I am with him on a visa in the US) until I am able to work. There is also the age gap between us. I am 22 while my fiancee is 45. I worry I will be taking care of his grandfather until he passes, and then I will be taking care of my fiancee until he passes after. I want children and my own clean, well functioning home. There is no home at his grandfather's house. It is a wreck. And there is no money for repairs or to bring in professionals because the only person with that kind of money is the one person who refuses to spend it. The grandfather. My fiancee and I both provide hygiene products, clothes, house shoes anything someone should have to be clean and comfortable, it is a matter of they go "missing" or are later found in a closet (like I mentioned was the case with the diapers in the first post). He uses a cardboard box as a foot stool after we bought him a lovely foot rest from a furniture store. It's not that the house does not get cleaned or the grandfather provided for, it is that he refuses to ask for assistance to lessen the mess or alert us that it's there in a timely manner. Professionals at this point would only say what I already know, and repeat what I have already told my fiancee. It's as if there is literally no escaping. What was his promise, is now my nightmare and I guess I resent them both a little bit. The grandfather for acting the way he does, and my fiancee for not telling me any of the details when we first met and began dating. I feel as though I was ambushed at times and I am the only one seeing the problem while everyone else sees it as normal and routine because my fiancee didn't know what to do when he began the care.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

About the promise to the dying grandmother: I think it is admirable that the young man wants to honor that promise. Sometimes, as cmagnu points out, circumstances change and promises cease to make sense or to be do-able. In this case, though, I think it is perfectly possible to "take care of" grandfather as long as he lives. But taking care does not have to mean living in a gross environment or ignoring potential medical issues. It sounds like Grandfather might have congestive heart failure (from the description of his walking problems) and possibly dementia. He needs a thorough geriatric evaluation. I know that the fiancee is doing the best he can. I don't think it is good enough. He is acting from his heart but it is time to engage the head as well.

And why is the house falling down around them? If grandson has been living there for 10 years, why haven't repairs been made? Good for him about the heating and cooling. But that is not enough. If he is paying rent, he could withhold rent to bring the plumbing up to code. If he isn't paying rent, why isn't he contributing to the upkeep where he is living? Grandfather is too cheap (or demented) to buy soap and toothpaste? Surely Grandson can supply those things. There are aspects of this picture that are very puzzling. I know that we don't have all the details.

Grandfather is a slob. Maybe he has been all his life, and maybe this is new health-related behavior. Grandson has a job and a fiancee and is trying to have a life. OK. How about hiring a cleaning service?

I think Grandson should start living up to the spirit of the promise to "take care" of his grandfather. When he was younger and grandfather was healthy but loney, it meant stopping by to keep him company. Then it meant helping with the yardwork. Those were things Grandson could do. Great. But as the needs increased, I think Grandson simply got in over his head. No shame in that. We are not born knowing how to care for the elderly. But to honor that promise to his wonderful grandmother, I think it is time to bring in professionals who are trained in dealing with the specific issues Grandfather needs help with.

I would be proud if any of my grandchildren worked so hard to honor a promise they made to me. I realy would. But I would be crushed to see any of them do it in a way that interfered with living their own lives to the fullest. I hope they all know me well enough to understand I would never wish for that.

I guess this isn't any advice for you, stl. It is just another perspective to consider.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

stl...Caregiving is a very hard hard hard road. I applaud your b/f immensely to being sweet enough to take care of his grandfather. Bravo to him for doing so. I just lost my mom recently and when I started the venture 2 years ago thought I was going to go insane...but trudged through the thick and the thin and at the very end was with her on Family Leave for the past 3 months and GLAD I DID IT. My mother never wanted to go to a nursing home..and when I did check out long term care found it HIDEOUS..at least the ones around me..in a middle class neighboorhood at that... My suggestion..and only a suggestion mind you is to keep at it...since you know Social work already you should know a lot of what lies ahead. The poor old man you must know may not know what he is doing, and putting the foot down does not always help. You think they know what they are doing but sometimes really not...the mind does deteriorate with age. He may not know what he is doing but thinks he does. I would wait until after perhaps grandpa is no longer living with you before you get married and carry forward....this might make your relationship stronger - the two of you working together with the same goals..it's part of life. Think of grandpa and his life he has lead and just to be thrown out after all this at an old age....we all get old...and we don't want to be tossed away. I would glean the best of what you read here....hang on to yer britches and go for the long haul...it will make you a better person in the end...I really think so. Remember we all get old and will be in the same boat one day.

Hey bobbie I said boat...lol!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

In a nutshell, this all comes down to healthy boundaries. It is not an ultimatim to say that for my own health and the health of our relationship there needs to be some new boundaries that were not there before because we are preparing for a major life change. I had to do this with my wife concerning how enmeshed she was with her mother. Boundaries are not so much a means of changing or punishing someone as they are healthy self-protection. You and your future husband have some serious soul searching questions to face openly and honestly with each other. You already know this as a social worker, but it is harder to remember with ones own family to own your own feelings when sharing them using I statements instead of you statements because they also tend to not put the other person on the defensive. One of the hardest lessons anyone in a profession like social work, counseling, nursing, pastoral ministry, etc. has to learn is becoming seasoned without becoming hardened or reacting to people's problems so strongly that you burn out. Take care of yourself.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Wow! I appreciate the comments and advice so much. I was really scared I would be judged or perceived as having ulterior motives in the beginning. As the story keeps unraveling, I am still thinking through mentioning some things to my fiancee but all it sounds like is a big fat ultimatum. He knows I am disgusted by his grandfather's poor diet and hygiene. I am constantly pushing my fiancee to stand up to his grandfather and take charge. How can one be a caregiver when they are not doing what someone who cares would do? Even if it means putting your foot down! I realize on my own I am not going to change the situation or make my fiancee leave his grandfather, but I can point out the differences between his grandfather's wants and needs. One thing is for sure, we have bumped heads over that old man and sitting in the hospital being told by a social worker that the conditions of the house I spend 90% of my time in is "gross" was definitely embarrassing. But my health being affected by caring for a loved one, relation or not, something that should be easy, is where I draw the line. And I want my fiancee to draw that line with me. What I want him to understand is his grandpa has lived a full, happy life. He had a wife for 41 years and now he needs to let his grandson experience his life and stop being so stubborn because it only creates more work and more stress for us. I am now learning to fear what my grandmother will be like in a few years. She is still the same sweet, funny, busy body lady she has been my whole life and I hope I never took how wonderful she is for granted. And I see not everyone has it as easy breezy. But I also hope my fiancee, and anyone else can realize that "outsiders"| point things out because we CARE not because we are nosey or want all the attention or want to move anyone out of the way. I love my fiancee and his grandpa, but I KNOW there is no way he would make it on his own and that's why I WILL bring up the option of a nursing home. Thanks again for the continued comments, advice and support.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

It is sad to read of one more caught in a situation like your future husband in fear of guilt over an obligation promised years ago. As an adult, he is free to change his mind in light of the current situation now with his grandfather vs back then as well as his being single then and now preparing to get married. However, it is not up to you to fix this, but the more I read,(thanks for telling us more) the more I think you would be within your rights to say let us get some counseling before we get married and maybe an objective third person could help sort these things out without you having to get triangulated between him and his grandfather.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Wow, stil, wow.
You already know that if you marry into this situation you will have a lot of stress over it and it will affect your marriage.
naheaton has it right.
to me it sounds like the poor grandfather has dementia and is somewhat of a hoarder.
My mom was doing stuff like that... house was in shambles, hoarded useless things, etc etc when I intervened in 04. I had no idea that she was in such trouble. She was angry and mean at that time and it was no walk in the park to figure out what to do and how to do it.
For you and your sweetheart to have any kind of healthy future, it must be the two of you first.
So many times someone, on their deathbed, will elicit a promise that simply cannot be kept.
This is one of those times.
I am so sorry that you are getting sucked into what I call the 'vortex of dementia'. I think that for someone like your sweetheart, it is like the frog in the frying pan. you don't realize how bad it has become until you see it through someone else's eyes. It just gets worse and worse until you are trapped.
good luck and keep posting.

wow to you too rojones, what a mess that is.
Abuse is abuse and not to be tolerated. Call Adult protective Services on the sly and see what can be done to assist the parents in their home. You may be able to help and get them assistance so the daughter can move on down the road and not spend her time screaming and scaring her parents. So wrong on so many levels and more prevalent than anyone could even imagine.
Letting off steam is one thing but what she is doing is not venting, it's abuse.
good luck to you too.
lovbob
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Your situation is nothing like mine at all. And I think you are doing a great thing by stepping up and caring for her parents. However, what you are seeing is the classic case of elder abuse and you should report it. At the very least confront your friend so she is aware you have taken notice and maybe she will mind what she says to her parents from now on and follow your lead and care for them the way a daughter should care for her parents. Sounds like the parents might also have some money saved up if they can allow you and your friend to live there for free to maybe have a relief worker come into their home once or twice a week to give you and your friend a break which could also help you work on your friendship.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I presently am living with a friend and her parents that are 87 and 88...my home foreclosed and i had nowhere to go..my friend opened up here home for me to stay and her parents were just as gracious..after 7 months of being here..i have come to witness that my friend is not who I thought she was or who she had claimed...she lives rent free and very comfortably with her parents (so, do I at this time too)..and my friend has shown me a side that is immature and mean and cold to her aging parents...she manipulates and uses and yells and screams and calls them names when refused money or something she wanted..she will even go as far as punish them by not cooking or grocery shopping or helping them with day to day living...i naturally jumped in and started helping her parents out as much as possible...from doctor appts, now to writing out their bills..they have learned to rely on me more than their daughter...i am not a mean ugly person, but a decent honest person that respects people..especially my own mom and dad that passed away several years ago.

well, now my friend has seen my actions with parents and now has started a cold war with me and refuses to speak to me and has been trying to damage my credibility and reputation with parents by making up lies, claiming false accusations regarding theft, etc..luckily, her parents have defended me to her and know that they are all lies...it has escalated to a very ugly situation in the house...

I am torn now, because I am very concerned about the welfare of her parents if I was to leave the home, since I feel like I am being bullied and pushed out forcibly...if left with daughter, i worry if they will be alright...i cannot stand to see them hurt and know this is how they are to spend their last years on earth...they are such a beautiful couple and like my own parents...
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

My best advice to you STL is to wait. Don't rush into getting married until you've got yourself established. I see trouble on the horizon for you in thinking that your fiancee will even consider moving his grandpa into asst living or a nursing home. The fact that you haven't discussed it with him yet, tells me you're worried too. Get out on your own, do your social work, get yourself going by yourself and see what happens. I think it's wonderful that your fiancee has stepped up to help his grandfather, so don't expect things to change just because you're coming into the picture, related or not.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

There is more than one way to take care of a person. Would his grandmother really be pleased at the way her husband is now living? Would she shake her head and mutter, "Boy, I told you to take care of him, not let him live in a pigstye! Do you think care means lettin' somebody do every dang thing they want?"

You can influence. You can suggest. You can educate. But ultimately the only person whose behavior you can control is you. I think if you read through your own posts tomorrow or next week you will see that you have already made up your mind about some things. Or maybe I'm wrong and you are just venting. Try it in a few days and see what you think.

PS. Grandfather may "slip away" within the year or in fifteen years. Keep that in mind.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

1 2 3
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter